When you are craving authentic flavors and family recipes, our bakery in Sarasota is the ultimate destination. From our humble beginnings to our expansive menu today, we are building our empire one hard roll at a time.
A Look Inside the Paisano's Bakery Menu
A Look Inside the Paisano's Bakery Menu
Authentic New England Style Pizza and Calzones
At Paisano's Italian Bakery, we bring a taste of Rhode Island to Florida with our signature New England style pizza strips. Whether you prefer them with rich sauce, melted cheese, or fresh pepperoni, they are a savory staple. We also handcraft hearty calzones, including the classic Godfather stuffed with sausage, meatballs, peppers, and cheese, offering a perfect, savory meal.
Decadent Pastries and Biscotti
No visit is complete without treating yourself to our traditional Italian pastries. We offer everything from crispy, cream-filled small and large cannolis to flaky lobster tails and sweet sfogliatelle. If you love a satisfying crunch with your coffee, our extensive selection of biscotti, featuring flavors like pistachio, toasted almond, and chocolate chunk, will hit the spot.
Delectable Cookies for Every Occasion
Our cookie trays are legendary and packed with a variety of textures and flavors. We pride ourselves on offering authentic pignolis, vibrant rainbow cookies, and classic black and white cookies. Whether you are grabbing a quick treat or bringing a platter to a party, our butter cookies and seasonal favorites are always a hit.
Custom Cakes and Food To-Go
Beyond everyday treats, we create beautiful custom cakes and cupcakes for weddings, birthdays, and celebrations. For those busy nights, our food to-go menu has you covered with comforting classics like cheese lasagna, stuffed shells, and fresh marinara. It is the perfect way to enjoy a home-cooked Italian meal without the hassle.
Ready to indulge your cravings?
Visit our Italian bakery in Sarasota today or contact us to place a custom order!