bakery text.png

Our Baked Goods

Building our empire one hard roll at a time

Custom Order Form



Stop by Paisano's today and indulge in our scrumptious baked goods. Keep in mind our menu is subject to change.


At Paisano’s Italian Bakery, we hand make delicious calzones and New England style pizza. Our Italian dishes are sure to tantalize your taste buds! Check out the items we have on our menu.

  • Spinach & Mozzarella Calzone
  • Eggplant Calzone (cheese free option!)
    • Eggplant and sauce
  • Italian Calzone
    • Ham, salami, cheese, and banana peppers
  • Godfather Calzone
    • Sausage, meatballs, peppers, cheese, and sauce
  • Strips With Sauce — New England Style Pizza
  • Strips With Cheese — New England Style Pizza
  • Strips With Pepperoni — New England Style Pizza
  • Fresh Tomato Squares — New England Style Pizza
  • Vegetable Squares - New England Style Pizza


For customers who need to pick up food and take it on the go, Paisano’s got you covered. Our to-go options include:

  • Eggplant Marinara

  • Eggplant Roulade

  • Cheese Lasagna (meat free)

  • Stuffed Shells

    • Ricotta, mozzarella, and italian herbs

  • Italian Meatballs (beef)

  • Italian Wedding Soup

  • Dough (1lb, freshly made same day)

  • Pizza Sauce (16oz, freshly made)

  • Marinara (16oz, freshly made)

  • Fresh Mozzarella (two 4oz balls)

  • Fresh Parmesan (16oz freshly grated)


Paisano's pastries are a delightful treat for all occasions. Our Italian baked goods are made with a passion for flavor and quality. With a wide selection of pastry options, you can always find something unique and tasty to try! Our pastries are:

  • Small & Large Cannoli
  • Creme Brulee
  • Key Lime Tarts
  • Cannoli Tarts
  • Chocolate Lava Cake
  • Cassata Cake Roll
  • Muffins
  • Apple Coffee Cake
  • Cinnamon Coffee Cake
  • Hamentash
  • Swiss Roll
  • Zeppoli
  • Tiramisu
  • ​Cheesecake (Traditional & Berry)
  • Cream Horns
  • Lobster Tails
  • Ricotta Pie
  • Cheesecake Brownie
  • Baby Cheesecakes
  • Cream Puffs
  • Dumbells
  • Mini Eclairs
  • Buckeyes​
  • Chocolate Marsala Mousse Puffs
  • Brownies
  • Pecan Squares
  • Lemon Bars
  • Unconditional Surrender Bars (chocolate chip cookie base filled with Oreos, covered in cheesecake)
  • Napoleons
  • Jumbo Eclairs
  • Triple Chocolate Bars
  • Cinnamon Sticks
  • Small & Large Sfogliatelle
  • Lemon Squares
  • Fig Squares
  • BlueberryTurnover
  • Raspberry Turnover
  • Apple Turnover
  • ​Cake Pops

Cookies & Butter Cookies

Paisano’s Bakery has some of the best baked goods in Sarasota, and the cookies and butter cookies are no exception. These delectable treats are sure to satisfy even the most discerning of sweet tooths. We have:

  • Almond Crescents

  • Pignolis

  • Cuccidati

  • Black & White Cookies

  • Rainbow Cookies

  • Coconut Macaroons

  • Hazelnut Slices

  • Lady Kisses

  • Sesame Cookies

  • Chocolate Hearts

  • Florentines

  • Raspberry Happiness

  • Hand Painted Sugar Cookies

  • Sugared Cookies

  • Bachelor Buttons (seasonal)

  • Shortbread

  • Walnut Slices

  • Chocolate M&M's — Butter Cookies

  • Chocolate Sandwiches — Butter Cookies

  • Apricot Sandwiches — Butter Cookies

  • Chocolate Dipped — Butter Cookies

  • White Chocolate Dipped — Butter Cookies

  • Raspberry — Butter Cookies

  • Chocolate Sprinkles — Butter Cookies

  • Rainbow Sprinkle — Butter Cookies

  • Raspberry Seashell — Butter Cookies

  • Chocolate Fans — Butter Cookies

8 & 6” Cakes, Cake Slices, & Cupcakes

We have a variety of delectable cake and cupcakes flavors to beat your sweet tooth. Whether you are looking for a classic cake or something a little more unique, Paisano's has you covered.

8” Cakes generally serve 8-10.

6” Cakes generally serve 4-6.

  • Vanilla — 8” Cakes & Cupcakes
  • Chocolate — Cupcakes

  • Boston Cream — 8” Cakes

  • Cannoli — 8” Cakes & Cake Slice

  • Triple Chocolate — 8” Cakes, Cake Slices

  • Red Velvet — 8” Cakes & Cupcakes

  • Carrot — 8” Cakes, Cake Slices, & Cupcakes

  • Italian Cream — 8” Cakes & Cake Slices

  • Tiramisu — 8” Cakes & Squares

  • Rum Cake — 8” Cakes & Cake Slices

  • Chocolate Mousse — Cake Slices

  • Lemon Coconut — Cake Slices (seasonal)

  • Peanut Butter Passion — Cake Slices

  • Death By Chocolate — Cake Slices

  • Confetti - 6” Cake

  • Chocolate Raspberry - 6” Cake


Paisano's biscotti is the perfect treat for anyone who loves Italian baked goods. These traditional Italian cookies have been crafted by skilled bakers using only the finest ingredients. The result is a crispy and crunchy biscotti that is sure to satisfy. Sold by weight.

  • Almond
  • Chocolate Walnut
  • Cranberry Pistachio
  • Toasted Almond
  • Chocolate Chunk Pistachio
  • Amaretto White Chocolate
  • Cherry Chunk
  • Anise

New England Style Pizza & Calzones

At Paisano's Italian Bakery, we offer delicious, hand-made calzones and New England-style pizzas, sure to tantalize your taste buds. Our menu is full of Italian dishes that are sure to please. Try one of our delicious creations today at our Sarasota location!

Spinach & Mozzarella Calzone

The Spinach & Mozzarella Calzone from Paisano's Bakery is the perfect combination of simplicity and deliciousness. This calzone is filled with fresh spinach and gooey mozzarella cheese — a classic flavor combination that will satisfy your hunger.

Eggplant Calzone (Cheese-Free Option Available)

The Eggplant Calzone from Paisano's Italian Bakery is a flavorful, vegetarian option that is a great way to enjoy an Italian classic. We also offer a cheese-free option, so stop by Paisano's today and try the Eggplant Calzone — you won't regret it!

Italian Calzone

This delicious dish is packed with fresh ingredients like ham, salami, cheese, and banana peppers, making it a hearty and flavorful meal. If you are looking for something unique, the Italian Calzone is sure to satisfy.

Godfather Calzone

The Godfather Calzone from Paisano's Bakery is a must-have for any fan of Italian cuisine! This delicious calzone is packed with savory sausage, meatballs, peppers, cheese, and sauce. Come to Paisano's Bakery and try the Godfather Calzone today!

  • Strips With Sauce - New England-Style Pizza
  • Strips With Cheese - New England-Style Pizza
  • Strips With Pepperoni - New England-Style Pizza
  • Fresh Tomato Squares - New England-Style Pizza
  • Vegetable Squares - New England-Style Pizza

At Paisano's Italian Bakery, we offer deliciously hand-made calzones and New England-style pizzas that you won't be able to resist! Our menu has a variety of Italian dishes for any taste, like the Eggplant Calzone for vegetarian options, the Spinach & Mozzarella Calzone for a simple combination of flavors, and the Italian Calzone or Godfather Calzone for something with a little extra kick. We also have a variety of New England-Style Pizzas that you have to try! So come on down to Paisano's Italian Bakery in Sarasota, Florida, today and satisfy your hunger!

Get In Touch Today